Adams v Carey Pensions – What does this now mean for Sipp Claims?

By Managing Director Sarah Stokes

The High Court ruled on one of the most anticipated cases in negligent Sipp Provider history a few weeks ago, in the Adams v Carey Pension case.

Mr Adams argued that Carey Pensions were responsible for significant losses to his pension fund after he transferred an existing pension into a SIPP they administered. The judgement dismissed the case on all grounds ruling that Carey acted as a non-advisory pensions administrator via an execution-only contract.

The case threw up many talking points around the role and requirements of the Provider, what obligations they have regarding the use of Unregulated Introducers and how Guidance set out by the Financial Conduct Authority is not necessarily legally binding.

 

Why did The High Court find in favour of Carey Pensions and not Adams?

The High Court made judgements based strictly under the Financial Service Market Act, they did not pay much attention to the regulators Guidance.

In the cold light of day, there is not much to protect the consumer under the Financial Service Market Act. This means the much discussed ‘treating customers fairly’ notion has been pretty much bypassed since it falls under ‘Guidance’ – rather than any binding law.

 

But why were Carey Pensions, as Provider, not liable for the unregulated advice given to Adams? 

Because Carey’s did not give the unregulated advice. A firm called Commercial Land and Property (CL&P) did. CL&P acted as Introducers for Careys, and gave unregulated advice, even though they were not authorised to do so.

The High Court found that Careys were unaware of this advice and that the arrangement between them as Provider and CL&P as Introducer was not a joint venture. In fact, Careys involvement was merely an ‘execution only’ contract, meaning the regulatory requirements (set out by the FCA) did not supersede the execution only contract – which the consumer was deemed responsible for.

 

Will this case have an effect on future Financial Ombudsman Service rulings?

The Judge stated this is not a landmark case, although precedents could be laid down because of it, especially if the ruling is upheld on appeal. However, the FCA were quick to say the High Court ruling does not change Guidance and Requirements.

 

Do you think SIPP Providers will learn anything from the Adams V Carey Pensions case?

If this case is anything to go by, it shows how little attention some SIPP Providers pay to the regulators Reviews and Guidance, so it could be the case the outcome of the Adams v Carey case sends out the wrong message.

 

Have Pension Claim Consulting had any recent claims against Carey Pensions?

Last May Pension Claim Consulting won a claim on behalf of a gentleman referred to as Mr T. The timing was ironic as it was within a couple of weeks of the High Court throwing out Adam’s claim against Carey. The point is, we went through the Financial Services Ombudsman and were successful – the claims were very similar.

Both claims related to Carey Pensions accepting a Sipp application from unregulated introducer Terence Wright and his firm CL&P. The difference was that The High Court accepted the ‘Execution basis only’ argument from Carey. The FOS would not have done so. Wright was of course on the FCA warning list as far back as 2010, yet Carey continued to accept business from his firm as highlighted in our claim.

 

Our Free Initial Assessment

If you have concerns about the pension advice you received or the investments held within your pension, we can carry out a free initial assessment.
We’ll review the information you provide, explain whether there may be grounds to make a complaint and discuss the options that may be available.
There is no obligation to use our service.
Posted on Google Google
Val Hetherington
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Pension Claim Consulting has been a totally reassuring, professional company throughout the process. I received compensation after following their advice and the company kept me informed throughout. i feel that their invoice for payment at the end of the successful claim is very fair and certainly not exorbitant. I would like to thank the company staff for their support, advice and professionalism.
Posted on Google Google
Colin Corrodus
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Excellent support. Provided regular updates and although my claim too longer than expected they swiftly responded in seeking more clarification from FSCS and getting it sorted. I got compensation which was way above expectations so very happy customer.
Posted on Google Google
Tony Manning
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Thank you Sarah,Zoe,Megan and the rest of the team for successfully winning my complaint for a defined benefit transfer mis-selling back in 1994, your team continuously kept me updated throughout my claim, I cannot thank you enough for your excellent professional service and would highly recommend Pension Claim Consulting.
Posted on Google Google
The Lifestyle Concept
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Without a doubt, one of the most professional and kind claims companies I have ever had the pleasure to encounter. I was in a very difficult mental place when I contacted this company, and it took over five years to win back what was rightfully mine. I cannot speak highly enough of them. They are quite simply, the best.
Posted on Google Google
Mahomed Jogee
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
I dealt with Pension Claim Consulting Ltd and over the years, I found they were very active. They updated me with progress on my claim. I did not have to chase them for any updates. I would use them again. Keep up your good work.
Posted on Google Google
Bridget Sanderson
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Excellent service, great customer support and communication throughout
Posted on Google Google
Rosamund Bloss
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Absolutely fantastic company, kept me informed on a regular basis , with advice on the process of my claim, can't thank them enough. EXCELLENT SERVICE
Posted on Google Google
Clive Bailey
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Have been very pleased with these people. They have stuck at my claim and updted me very regualrly so I knew it ws not forgotteen. Very happy with the service recieived particularly as on a no-win no-fee basis.
Posted on Google Google
Henrietta Darko
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Pension claim were absolutely amazing in supporting my mum in her miss sold pension. They kept us updated throughout the whole process and were always so polite, professional and reassuring. They made us feel confident in them and we are so glad we came across them. We were thankful for the reviews left by others as well as this helped us make the decision to contact them. So if you find yourself in this position and wonder who to contact to support you please choose pension claim because they have been amazing. Thank you so much pension claim consulting!
Posted on Google Google
robert hayes
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
Since 2020 they have dealt professionally with my case and have represented me without very little input from myself. Very impressed with the outcome they have achieved on my behalf. Many thanks to all at Pension Claim Consulting.

Contact address

Pension Claim Consulting
3 Stokes House
Stubley Lane
Dronfield
S18 1PG

Email: contactus@pensionclaimconsultingltd.co.uk
Phone: 0114 266 4216
Monday to Friday, 9am–5pm

Contact our team

Arrange a free consultation or ask us a question. A member of our team will be in touch.
GDPR consent*

Important information

You are not required to use our services to pursue a claim. You may seek further advice or shop around, subject to any time limits. You can present a claim for free to the firm or person you wish to complain about, the Financial Ombudsman Service, the Pensions Ombudsman Service or the Financial Services Compensation Scheme, depending on your claim.

If you use our service, our success fee is 15% plus VAT of the gross compensation offered, capped at £7,500 plus VAT. If we do not secure an offer of compensation, you will not pay a success fee. Cancellation charges may still apply if you cancel before the claim process is complete.

We will not make or pursue a claim, or advise you to do so, if we know or have reasonable grounds to suspect that it has no good arguable basis, or is fraudulent or frivolous.
Pension Claim Consulting Ltd is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority in respect of regulated claims management activities (FRN 829766).
Registered with the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO), registration ZA128514. Registered in England and Wales, company number 9626782. Registered office: 3 Stokes House, Stubley Lane, Derbyshire, S18 1PG.

© Pension Claim Consulting 2026 · Website designed and built by Brand North | Website Design Sheffield
Summary of Service Client Agreement Cancellation Complaint Procedure Privacy Policy Cookie Policy