The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has announced decisive measures against four financial advisers for ‘reckless’ pension advice.
The FCA said it considers these individuals were responsible for providing a pension transfer advice model that potentially jeopardised clients’ guaranteed retirement benefits.
The regulatory body has decided to ban two financial advisers and two partners at St Martin’s Partners LLP (SMP) from working in financial services. It also imposed collective fines totalling £590,544.
The FCA’s investigation revealed that between October 2015 and July 2016, St Martin’s Partners LLP’s advice model exposed 547 customers to significant risks. These clients were advised to transfer out of guaranteed defined benefit pensions into potentially unsuitable investments.
The unsuitable investments recommended to customers include hotel developments in Cape Verde offered by The Resort Group Plc.
According to the FCA, many of those customers were brought to St Martin’s Partners LLP by ‘introducer’ firms. One of which was First Review Pension Services Ltd (FRPS), a subsidiary of The Resort Group.
It’s the FCA’s view that St Martin’s Partners LLP had clear indications of the link between FRPS and The Resort Group.
Therese Chambers, Joint Executive Director of Enforcement and Market Oversight at the FCA, stated: “People need to be able to trust the advice they receive about their pensions. But these four individuals put SMP’s customers in danger of giving up guaranteed retirement income for high-risk investments, like overseas hotel developments. They received significant financial benefit in doing so, at the expense of their customers.”
Adrian Douglas and Liam Martin are both qualified pension advisers. The FCA said they played important roles in designing and operating the transfer advice model. The FCA has decided to fine each of them £128,356 and ban them from working in financial services.
Frank Oxberry, a partner at SMP, is facing a fine of £241,869 and a ban from the financial services industry.
Alec Cuthbert, another partner at SMP, has been fined £91,963 and banned from working in financial services. Unlike the others, Cuthbert agreed to settle the FCA’s case against him.
The FCA highlighted that St Martin’s Partners LLP’s advice model failed to consider essential information required to assess the suitability of pension transfers. The firm also neglected to compare the benefits of customers’ existing schemes with the proposed new investments.
It’s worth noting that Mr Douglas, Mr Martin, and Mr Oxberry have referred their Decision Notices to the Upper Tribunal. There the final determination will be made regarding the FCA’s proposed actions.
The consequences of this misconduct have been severe. St Martin’s Partners LLP is now in liquidation. And the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) has already paid over £13.4 million in compensation to clients for losses suffered due to the advice they received.
This case serves as a stark reminder of the importance of thorough and ethical financial advice, particularly concerning pension transfers. The FCA’s actions underscore its commitment to protecting consumers and maintaining the integrity of the financial services industry.
