The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has fined a former director of Capital & Income Solutions £1.38 million for providing unsuitable pension transfer advice.
Alongside the fine, Philip Pryke, has been banned from carrying out any regulated financial activities.
Capital & Income Solutions (C&I) went into Administration in January 2020. It was declared in default by the FSCS later that year.
Between April 2015 and June 2019, Capital & Income Solutions advised 986 customers to transfer from defined benefit (DB) pension schemes to alternative arrangements.
These transfers amounted to £200 million, with an average transfer value of just under £200,000.
Following an investigation, the FCA determined that many of C&I’s recommendations were unsuitable and not in the clients’ best interests.
The FCA said it considers that Mr Pryke failed to act with integrity, paying scant regard to regulatory standards and requirements.
It accused Mr Pryke of prioritising the Firm’s profitability over the interests of its customers “thereby enabling him to fund a luxurious lifestyle.”
According to the final notice Capital & Income Solutions earned £8.1 million in in fees from pension transfer advice. This accounted for approximately 76% of the firm’s income during a 12-month period.
FCA guidance at the time was a ‘presumption of unsuitability’ in respect of transferring out of a Defined Benefit Pension.
Mis-sold pension transfers can have devastating consequences for consumers.
The Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) has received 1,300 claims from affected Capital & Income Solutions (C&I) customers.
As at September 2023, it had upheld 766 claims agains and paid out £42.5 million in compensation.
However, due to the compensation limit of £85,000 per claim, the total amount owed to customers is estimated to be closer to £67 million.
Pryke personally acted as the pension transfer specialist in 81% of upheld claims. In 305 cases, claimants were awarded the maximum compensation available under the scheme.
