The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) is consulting on proposals to strengthen due diligence standards for Self-Invested Personal Pension (SIPP) operators.
The regulator says most SIPP operators are already doing the right thing and providing a good service to their customers. However, it has also highlighted historical examples of poor due diligence, weak record keeping and gaps in how some firms protected client money and assets.
According to the FCA, consumers experienced approximately £526 million in uncompensated financial losses across 22 SIPP operator failures between 2011 and 2023, largely where losses exceeded the FSCS compensation limit.
So, what is SIPP due diligence, why does it matter, and what does the FCA’s latest consultation mean for pension savers?
SIPP due diligence refers to the checks and assessments a SIPP operator carries out before accepting investments into a Self-Invested Personal Pension. These checks are intended to help the operator identify whether an investment meets its acceptance criteria and regulatory obligations.
Due diligence does not guarantee that an investment will perform well. Instead, it is intended to help ensure appropriate checks are carried out before investments are accepted into a SIPP.
The FCA says its proposals are intended to create greater consistency across the SIPP market while preserving the flexibility and investment choice that SIPPs can offer.
According to the regulator, it has historically identified examples of:
The consultation also proposes stronger requirements around the handling of pension scheme assets with a focus on helping reduce the risk of consumer harm if firms cease trading.
The proposals build on existing FCA expectations but aim to provide clearer and more consistent standards for SIPP operators.
Over the years, some SIPP operators held higher-risk or non-standard investments within pension arrangements. Examples include overseas property developments, storage pod investments, forestry schemes and mini-bonds.
In some cases, these investments later failed, became difficult to sell or suffered substantial losses. As a result, questions were often raised about:
These issues have contributed to complaints and compensation claims from consumers. In some cases, concerns have been raised that inadequate due diligence, unsuitable financial advice or the actions of other firms involved contributed to consumers investing in unsuitable or high-risk investments that later suffered losses.
The FCA’s consultation follows a number of high-profile SIPP operator failures over the past decade, several of which have led to complaints, FSCS claims and lengthy administration processes.
Recent examples include Hartley Pensions, Gaudi Regulated Services and Corporate & Professional Pensions Limited (CPPL), which have attracted significant attention within the pensions industry, illustrating the disruption that can occur when a SIPP operator fails.
While the circumstances surrounding each operator were different, these cases demonstrate why governance, operational resilience and effective due diligence have become increasingly important across the SIPP market.
Not every complaint involving a SIPP relates to the SIPP operator.
In many cases, the key issue is the financial advice that led to the pension transfer or investment decision.
Examples may include:
This is why it is important not to assume that responsibility automatically rests with the SIPP operator. Depending on the circumstances, responsibility may instead lie with the financial adviser, advice firm or another regulated business involved in the transaction.
Every complaint depends on its individual facts, which is why a careful review of the advice, investments and firms involved is often needed before establishing whether there may be grounds for a complaint.
Millions of people use SIPPs successfully as part of their retirement planning, and the regulator has acknowledged that most SIPP operators already provide a good service to their customers.
However, the consultation reinforces the importance of:
For consumers, the consultation is a reminder that understanding who was responsible for the advice, investments and operation of a pension arrangement can be an important first step if something goes wrong.
SIPP due diligence refers to the checks and assessments a SIPP operator carries out before accepting investments into a Self-Invested Personal Pension. The aim is to ensure appropriate standards are followed before investments are accepted.
All investments carry risk and the potential for losses, so losing money does not automatically mean you have grounds for a complaint. Depending on the circumstances, a SIPP operator may be responsible where it has failed to meet its regulatory obligations. In other cases, responsibility may instead rest with a financial adviser or another firm involved. Each complaint depends on its own facts and circumstances.
A SIPP operator administers the pension arrangement, while a financial adviser may recommend pension transfers or investments. They perform different roles and have different responsibilities. Depending on the circumstances, responsibility for a complaint may rest with one or more parties.
Where concerns exist about the advice that led to a pension transfer or investment decision, it may be possible to make a complaint, depending on the circumstances and the applicable time limits.
No. A SIPP operator entering administration or being declared in default does not automatically mean a complaint will succeed. Each case depends on its own facts and circumstances.
This article was produced by Pension Claim Consulting Ltd, an FCA-authorised claims management company (CMC) (FRN 829766).
Pension Claim Consulting specialises in reviewing complaints about unsuitable and mis-sold pensions and investments, including Self-Invested Personal Pensions (SIPPs), defined benefit (DB) pension transfers and Free-Standing Additional Voluntary Contributions (FSAVCs).
Our content is based on official sources, regulatory developments and FCA guidance to help readers understand complex issues and make informed decisions about their options.
Last reviewed: July 2026
